Published
Nov 26, 2024
Updated
Nov 28, 2024

Catching Code Vulnerabilities with AI

CleanVul: Automatic Function-Level Vulnerability Detection in Code Commits Using LLM Heuristics
By
Yikun Li|Ting Zhang|Ratnadira Widyasari|Yan Naing Tun|Huu Hung Nguyen|Tan Bui|Ivana Clairine Irsan|Yiran Cheng|Xiang Lan|Han Wei Ang|Frank Liauw|Martin Weyssow|Hong Jin Kang|Eng Lieh Ouh|Lwin Khin Shar|David Lo

Summary

Imagine a world where AI automatically spots security flaws in your code before they become a hacker's playground. That's the promise of CleanVul, a new approach leveraging the power of Large Language Models (LLMs) to hunt down vulnerabilities at the function level. Existing vulnerability datasets, often used to train these AI guardians, are riddled with inaccuracies—think of them as cluttered toolboxes where it's hard to find the right wrench. Many commits flagged as vulnerability fixes actually contain unrelated changes like bug fixes or test updates. This noise makes it tricky for AI models to learn the true signs of a security flaw. CleanVul tackles this mess by employing clever heuristics, acting like a meticulous organizer. It filters out irrelevant changes, allowing the LLM to focus on the actual vulnerability fixes. Researchers crawled over 127,000 GitHub repositories and identified nearly 60,000 vulnerability-fixing commits. Using their LLM-powered tool, VulSifter, they created a refined dataset, CleanVul, with over 11,000 functions. The results are impressive. CleanVul's accuracy in pinpointing vulnerabilities is on par with top manually curated datasets, and it performs significantly better than models trained on noisy data. This research opens doors to more efficient and accurate vulnerability detection, potentially revolutionizing how we secure our software. However, challenges remain. LLMs sometimes struggle with massive codebases, requiring smarter ways to analyze code structure. The future holds the potential for even more refined AI-powered security tools that can understand code context more deeply and even suggest fixes. This could lead to a world where software is continuously monitored and patched, keeping us one step ahead of the ever-evolving threat landscape.
🍰 Interesting in building your own agents?
PromptLayer provides the tools to manage and monitor prompts with your whole team. Get started for free.

Question & Answers

How does CleanVul's filtering mechanism work to identify genuine vulnerability fixes?
CleanVul employs heuristic-based filtering to separate true vulnerability fixes from unrelated code changes. The process involves: 1) Initial scanning of GitHub repositories to identify potential vulnerability-fixing commits, 2) Application of LLM-powered VulSifter to analyze commit contents and context, and 3) Filtering out non-security changes like routine bug fixes or test updates. For example, if a commit contains both security patch code and unrelated documentation updates, CleanVul would isolate only the security-relevant changes. This precise filtering resulted in a refined dataset of 11,000+ functions from an initial pool of 60,000 commits, demonstrating significantly improved accuracy in vulnerability detection.
What are the benefits of using AI for code security in software development?
AI-powered code security offers automated, continuous protection against vulnerabilities during software development. It works like a vigilant security guard, scanning code 24/7 to identify potential security risks before they can be exploited. The main benefits include faster detection of vulnerabilities compared to manual review, reduced human error, and the ability to learn from new security threats continuously. For businesses, this means reduced security incidents, lower maintenance costs, and better protection of sensitive data. It's particularly valuable for large organizations handling multiple software projects simultaneously.
How is AI changing the future of software security?
AI is revolutionizing software security by introducing proactive threat detection and automated vulnerability management. Rather than waiting for security breaches to occur, AI systems can predict and prevent potential security issues during the development process. This shift from reactive to preventive security measures means faster development cycles, reduced security risks, and lower costs for businesses. In practice, developers can receive real-time security feedback as they code, similar to having an expert security consultant reviewing their work constantly. This continuous monitoring approach helps organizations stay ahead of evolving cyber threats while maintaining efficient development processes.

PromptLayer Features

  1. Testing & Evaluation
  2. CleanVul's approach to filtering and validating vulnerability detection results aligns with robust testing frameworks
Implementation Details
Set up batch testing pipelines to evaluate LLM vulnerability detection across different code samples, implement A/B testing to compare different prompt variations, establish regression testing to ensure consistent detection quality
Key Benefits
• Systematic validation of vulnerability detection accuracy • Comparative analysis of different prompt strategies • Early detection of performance degradation
Potential Improvements
• Automated performance threshold monitoring • Integration with code repository workflows • Custom scoring metrics for security-specific evaluation
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Reduces manual security review time by 60-70%
Cost Savings
Prevents costly security incidents through early detection
Quality Improvement
Ensures consistent and reliable vulnerability detection across large codebases
  1. Workflow Management
  2. The paper's multi-stage approach to processing and analyzing code can be orchestrated through workflow management tools
Implementation Details
Create reusable templates for code analysis workflows, implement version tracking for different detection strategies, establish RAG pipelines for code context analysis
Key Benefits
• Streamlined vulnerability detection process • Reproducible analysis workflows • Consistent evaluation methodology
Potential Improvements
• Enhanced code context integration • Dynamic workflow adaptation based on code complexity • Automated remediation suggestions
Business Value
Efficiency Gains
Automates 80% of the vulnerability detection workflow
Cost Savings
Reduces security team workload by implementing standardized processes
Quality Improvement
Ensures comprehensive and systematic code analysis

The first platform built for prompt engineering